体育仲裁立法之法律冲突研究

【作者】 王暐琦；

【导师】 谭明义；

【作者基本信息】 南京师范大学 ， 体育教育训练学， 2008， 硕士

【摘要】 文章以中国体育仲裁立法中出现的法律冲突作为研究对象,通过文献资料法、逻辑分析法、比较分析法、专家访谈法等方法述分析了体育仲裁的涵义、性质和体育纠纷解决手段的优势,研究了我国竞技体育纠纷解决机制的现状和问题。通过分析和研究,文章认为,建立我国体育仲裁制度已迫在眉睫;为完善中国体育法制建设,适应中国竞技体育发展的实际需求并与国际惯例接轨,中国应尽快设立体育仲裁制度。文章分析了中国体育仲裁立法的依据和相关法律文件,指出《体育法》是体育仲裁立法的直接依据,而《立法法》是体育仲裁立法的保障依据。《体育法》第33条规定“在竞技体育活动中发生纠纷,由体育仲裁机构负责调解、仲裁。体育仲裁机构的设立办法和仲裁范围由国务院另行规定”。但是《立法法》第8条第9款规定“诉讼和仲裁制度只能制定法律。”因此出现了两部法律之间的法律冲突。通过以法学理论为基础分析法律冲突产生的原因,文章认为《体育法》和《立法法》关于体育仲裁立法的冲突是源自法律规则的相对稳定与社会生活变迁的矛盾。论文的研究目的就是探讨体育仲裁立法中的法律冲突,并尝试提出解决法律冲突的方法,为完善《中华人民共和国体育法》的配套立法及构建中国体育仲裁制度提供理论参考和支持。针对体育仲裁立法中存在的法律冲突,文章以立法基本原理和法律冲突解决的基本原理为基础理论,指出在当前形势下要从我国体育实践出发,面对体育仲裁立法中存在的法律冲突,有三种切实可行的解决途径:1制定《体育仲裁法》;2修改《体育法》;3制定《体育仲裁暂行条例》,并对三种解决方法的利弊进行了分析。文章最后指出:立法中应保持法的稳定性、变动性和连续性相结合,避免出现新的法律冲突,使我国体育法体系不断完善,促进体育事业的持续、快速、健康发展,与国际接轨,并在我国物质文明和精神文明建设中发挥积极作用。更多还原

【Abstract】 this article takes the legal conflict which appears by the Chinese sports arbitration legislation as the object of study , Through literature, logic analysis, comparative analysis, expert interviews and other methods in the analysis of the meaning of Arbitration for Sport , nature and sports advantage of the means of dispute resolution, Comparative study of the international situation and development of Arbitration for Sport and China’ s athletics to the dispute settlement mechanism of the status and problems. Through analysis and comparison, the article maintains that the building of China’ s sports arbitration system has been imminent.The article has analyzed the Chinese sports arbitration legislation basis and the related legal document, pointed out that "Sports Law" is the sports arbitration legislation direct basis, but "Legislative Law" is the sports arbitration legislation safeguard basis. "Sports Law" Section 33 provides that "in competitive sports in the event of a dispute, by the sports arbitration body responsible for conciliation, arbitration. Arbitration for Sport to the establishment of institutions and the scope of the arbitration provisions by the State Council separately." But "Legislative Law" the 8th 9th article of stipulation "the lawsuit and the arbitration system can only make the law. " Thus emerged the conflict-of-laws. Through legal theory based on analysis of the causes for the conflict-of-laws, the article maintains that "Sports Law" and "legislation" of Arbitration for Sport Council on the conflict stems from the relative stability of the rule of law and social life changes of contradictionsCouncil of Arbitration for Sport against the existing conflict-of-laws, articles of legislation and the basic tenets of the law to resolve the conflict based on the basic principles of theory, pointing out that in the current situation from the country’ s sports and practical. in the face of the Legislative Council of Arbitration for Sport in conflict of laws, there are three kind of practical solution: 1 Develop a "Law of Arbitration for Sport" ; 2 revise "Sports Law"; 3 formulate "Sports Arbitration Temporary regulation", and has carried on the analysis to three kind of solution’s advantages.The article pointed out finally: In the legislation should maintain method the stability, the mobility and the continual disposition union, avoid presenting the new legal conflict, causes our country sports law system to consummate unceasingly, promotion sport cause continually, fast, healthy development, with the international trail connection, and plays the positive role in our country material civilization and the promotion of cultural and ethical progress.更多还原