节点文献

论我国刑法“违背妇女意志”之司法适用与立法完善

On Judicial Application and Legislative Improvement of "Violation of Women’s Will" in Chinese Criminal Law

【作者】 沈丽萍

【导师】 刘磊;

【作者基本信息】 苏州大学 , 法律, 2012, 硕士

【副题名】以美国刑法为借鉴

【摘要】 尽管“违背妇女意志”是强奸罪的本质已经成为通说,但现行刑法强奸罪的立法模式并未有妇女意志的体现,而更偏向于行为人的行为,对行为的解释也过于原则和简化,司法解释相对陈旧,已经不能满足客观形势的发展。在司法实践中对如何认定女性意志存在不同认识,对同一性质案件存在着截然相反的判决,立法者与司法者对于社会的性观念把握略显不足。因此,对强奸罪的理论研究急需进一步加强。笔者虽立足于女性主义的立场,但并不一味主张将妇女意志作为唯一标准,而应以客观行为与妇女意志相结合做判断。无论在司法还是立法中,我们都应立足于保护女性性自主权的立场,这样在对强奸罪的客观行为进行解释和适用时,才不至于让保护个人权利的愿望落空。如果不理清妇女意志在强奸罪中的地位,对强奸罪的判断也难免会有差池。本文将围绕强奸罪的本质择要探讨理论启示,并借鉴美国刑法辅以相关案例,对强奸案件尤其是行为手段方面所存在的问题进行了梳理并提出了自己的理论倾向,以期对强奸犯罪的理论研究和司法实践有所裨益。

【Abstract】 Although the saying "violation of women’s will" is the nature of the crime of rape hasbecome a common theory, the legislative mode of rape crime of existing criminal law isnot the manifestation of women’s will, and is more partial to the perpetrator’s behavior,what’s more, the interpretation of the behavior is usually of excessive principle andsimplified and the judicial interpretation is relatively old which can not meet thedevelopment of objective situation. There are different understandings of how to identifywomen’s will, and there are diametrically opposite judgments in terms of cases of samenature, with insufficient grasp of sexual attitudes in society by both of the legislator andjudicature. Therefore, to further strengthen the theoretical study of rape crime has becomean urgent need. Although the author stands on the feminist position but do not blindlyadvocate take the women’s will as the sole criterion, and shall judge from a combination ofobjective behavior and women’s will. We shall base on the standpoint of defending femalesexual autonomy whether in judiciary or legislation, so that the will to protect the rights ofindividuals would not come to nothing when we interpret and apply to the objectivebehavior of rape, and the judgment for rape would never fails to make mistake beforeclarifying the position of women’s will in rape. This thesis will focus on the nature of rapecrime, explore the theoretical implication selectively, furthermore, learn from the UnitedStates criminal law and supplemented by relevant cases, to comb the problems that existedin rape cases especially in the aspect of means behavior and put forward own theorytendency, thus expect to benefit the theoretical research and judicial practice of rape crime.

【关键词】 性自主权强奸女性主义同意
【Key words】 sexual independencerapefeminismconsent
  • 【网络出版投稿人】 苏州大学
  • 【网络出版年期】2012年 10期
  • 【分类号】D924.3
  • 【被引频次】2
  • 【下载频次】241
节点文献中: 

本文链接的文献网络图示:

本文的引文网络