杭州丁氏八千卷楼书事新考

【作者】 石祥；

【导师】 陈正宏；

【作者基本信息】 复旦大学 ， 中国古典文献学， 2006， 博士

【摘要】 本论文的研究对象是在我国藏书史上占有重要地位的杭州丁氏八千卷楼。论文主要考述丁氏藏书、刻书、著述、书籍交游即所谓“书事”活动，分为上、中、下三编。上编的考察范围为：丁氏八千卷楼藏书的聚散始末，丁氏与同时代藏书家、学者的交游情况。具体考述了丁氏的早期藏书状况，丁氏访求书籍的情况，丁氏藏书转归江南图书馆及零星散出的情况，丁氏与藏书家铁琴铜剑楼瞿氏、皕宋楼陆氏、寿松堂孙氏、艺风堂缪荃孙以及学者魏锡曾、傅以礼、王棻的书籍交往情况。其中丁氏早期藏书、其藏书零星散出的情况以及丁氏的书籍交往，在之前的研究中都较为薄弱。中编以《善本书室藏书志》、《八千卷楼书目》、《武林藏书录》三种丁氏家族成员的著述为研究对象，考述其编纂过程、体例特色与成就价值。在对《善本书室藏书志》的研究中，利用了稿钞本等一手材料，着重考察其与丁氏藏书题跋的关系、编纂经过、其中的作伪情况等之前研究未曾涉及或研究不充分的问题点，并依据材料对《善本书室藏书志》的善本标准进行了再讨论，提出其所收录版本的下限可晚至光绪，而同时又不收道光以降人物的著作。下编以丁氏编刻的《武林掌故丛编》、《武林往哲遗著》等丛书为研究对象，考述其编刻丛书的背景动机、始末经纬、编刻丛书与其师友交游的关系、编刻丛书的运作方式以及丛书刊刻所使用的底本等问题。其中，以丁氏的师友交游与其丛书编刻的关系这一全新的视角切入，观照了丁氏编刻丛书的实态，提出丁氏在编刻丛书中曾得益于多人的协助，双方在编刻丛书中的关系具有“利益共同体”的色彩。此外，利用文献材料和版本比对，考证了之前未有系统研究的丁氏刊刻丛书所用底本问题。此外，在各编中，还依据所掌握的材料，编制附录了多篇表录，以供参考。在论文写作方面，则以铺陈材料和考订分析相结合，力图清晰地还原、展现丁氏书事活动的关键节点，勾勒其整体面貌。本文对杭州丁氏的书事活动所作的个案研究，就微观而言，意在通过切实的文献证据，明晰其事实，分析其特点，探讨其价值；就学科研究而言，则为古文献学史、藏书史、出版史的研究提供了有效的例证；而就更加宏观的层面而言，则是从一个特定的视角，更清晰地反映藏书家这一特定的文化群体在学术史和文化史上的作用和贡献。更多还原

【Abstract】 Ding Bing’s Baqianjuanlou played an important role in Chinese book-collection history. This dissertation tries to have a systematic study on the activities concerning books of Ding Bing, such as the book collecting, printing and writing. It is divided into three chapters.Chapter I centers on the book-collection history of Ding’s Family and the friendship between Ding Bing and other contemporary book-collectors and scholars. Those topics disregarded before such as the scale of book-collection in Ding’s early years, the activities of seeking and collecting books, the transference of the collection to Jiangnan Library, the relationship with Qu yong’s tieqintongjianlou, Lu Xinyuan’s Bisonglou, Sun Yangzeng’s Shousongtang, Miao Quansun’s Yifengtang and the scholars such as Wei Xizeng, Fu Yili and Wang fen, have all been examined systematically in this chapter.Chapter II studies the compilation and the features and values of the three books An Annotated Bibliography of Rare Books Collected by Dingbing, An Bibliography of Baqianjuanlou and Anecdotes of Book-collection in Wulin City, which were written by the members of Ding’s Family. Making full use of the manuscripts in the study of An Annotated Bibliography of Rare Books Collected by Dingbing, this dissertation puts emphasis on the selecting criteria and compiling process of this book as well as the relation of its contents with other prefaces written by Ding Bing.Series compiled by Ding Bing such as Series of Books Concerning Wuli City and Series of Books Written by People of Wuli City are the subjects discussed in Chapter III. The problems such as the motives and the whole processes of compilation are all studied carefully. The question of the impact of Ding’s teachers and companions on these series is examined from a totally new perspective, suggesting that during the compilation Ding was helped by many others, who also benefited from the publication.Several appendixes were also provided for further reference.Through outlining the whole book-concern history of Ding Bing, this dissertation attempts to provide an example of research not only on the history of book-collection and publication but also on the history of studies of Chinese classics, and to reflect the donations the book-collectors made to Chinese academic and cultural history.更多还原