【摘要】 文章作者对刘锡庆先生的“文体净化说”提出了自己的看法和质询。第一 ,净化说 ,同“大散文说”一样 ,都属偏激之论 ,而且前者更甚 ,偏激而又固执。第二 ,净化说是论者自设的一把标尺 ,是一种没有现实根据的先验之论 ,是一个“伪话题”。第三 ,论散文不能就文体谈文体 ,反之则必然走向死胡同。第四 ,新世纪的散文需要整体全面的突破 ,要突破则必靠文化模式的改变 ,“净化说”于此无能为力更多还原

【Abstract】 This paper attempts to question and voice views on the notion of"stylistic purification" advanced by Liu Xi_qing in the following aspects.Firstly,the notion of purification,like that of grand prose,is radical and obdurate.Secondly,the notion of purification,a criterion set up by its proponent,is a groundless empirical one and thus a pseudotopic.Thirdly,the style of prose can not be studied or analysed from the perspective of style itself,or it may go nowhere.Fourthly,the prose in the new century is in need of an entire transformation to be activated by changes in cultural modes,to which the"purification"notion can contribute little.更多还原